Google Fiber and public infrastructure

There has been a great deal of positive coverage for Google Fiber’s rollout across two municipal areas (and because we’re talking about the US I’ll keep to their spelling of ‘fibre’.

One thing glossed over in most of the news coverage has been which level of society will benefit most. Michael Hiltzik has looked at this for the LA Times and concluded the people who won’t benefit are those who have most to gain from fast internet access: Those at the lowest levels of society.

As it is currently structured, the communities that will receive Google Fiber are those that band together to contribute financially to building the infrastructure. Naturally this the same group of people who can afford faster internet access anyway, not those further down the social ladder who could benefit from faster access to things like educational resources and job information.

Google has tried to put the best face on this by portraying the qualification process as a sort of community kumbaya, “allowing the citizens of City to determine where and when the Project will be deployed.” (The words come from Google’s contract with Kansas City, Mo.)

But that’s nonsense. Had the city tried to make that determination through its elected representatives, say by requiring service to underprivileged neighborhoods, Google’s response would have been, “Adios.” The company’s goal was to spend money where it was likeliest to attain a critical mass of customers. The inevitable outcome was an economic one: redlining.

LA Times

Once, big projects which needed the support of local government, like Google Fiber does, had to provide benefits for all members of the local community. This produced some of things we now take for granted, like access to clean water and electricity. Let’s hope Google Fiber doesn’t set a trend for businesses who want to run utility services being able to ignore ‘unprofitable’ groups.

Posted:

Written by .

Random posts…

The voice of an angel

From the bathroom her voice travelled throughout the house.

Posted: 25 September, 2010

When your favourite app sells out

If Facebook is a sprawling, intertextual garden of forking pokes, Instagram is no more complex than a chapbook of poetry

Posted: 10 April, 2012

Open and Closed

The tweeter was haranguing Apple (over multiple tweets) for being a closed platform.

Posted: 30 January, 2013

OS X LOTR LOL

Ever wondered what date Gandalf first visited Bilbo? Or when the War of the Ring finally ended? If you have Mac OS X then the answers lie within the Terminal app.

Posted: 30 November, 2012

Search

Keeping in touch